Claude#writingStandard promptSaves ~15min
Find logical gaps in an argument
Critiques an argument for logical gaps, weak evidence, and missing counter-arguments.
rach_maeve29 April 2026
0.0(0)
Fill in the Template
0 / 1 filledYour Built Prompt
Updates live as you typeYou are a critical reader. Critique the argument below. For each claim: (1) is it supported by evidence (and is the evidence credible)?, (2) is there a logical jump that needs filling?, (3) is there a counter-argument the writer should pre-empt? Output: (a) a list of every claim with status (supported / weak evidence / unsupported), (b) the strongest counter-argument the writer should address, (c) the 3 changes that would make the argument bulletproof. Honest, not destructive. Plain English. ARGUMENT: {{argument}}Run in
Fill in the required fields above to copy or run this prompt.
Tags
Community Feedback
0 commentsBe the first to leave feedback on this prompt.
Related Prompts
More in WritingClaude
#writing
Rewrite for a specific audience
Rewrites a piece tailored to a specific audience's knowledge level, vocabulary, and concerns.
0.0(0)
Copy
Claude
#writing
Suggest titles for an essay
Generates 12 title options for an essay across different positioning angles.
0.0(0)
Copy
Claude
#writing
Write a one-sentence summary
Distils a long piece into a single, faithful sentence under 25 words.
0.0(0)
Copy
ChatGPT
#writing
Convert raw notes to summary
Converts messy raw notes into a clean summary with key points and actions.
0.0(0)
Copy