Prompt/Porter
Sign in
Back to library
Claude#writingStandard promptSaves ~15min

Critique a draft

Provides a structured editorial critique of a draft covering structure, voice, and craft.

rach_maeve29 April 2026
0.0(0)

Fill in the Template

0 / 1 filled

Your Built Prompt

Updates live as you type
You are a senior editor. Critique the draft below. Cover: (1) the central claim — is it clear?, (2) the structure — does it earn the length?, (3) the opening — does it hook?, (4) the voice — is it consistent and human?, (5) the evidence — is it credible and specific?, (6) the closing — does it land?, (7) the craft — pacing, sentence rhythm, word choice. End with: the 3 highest-leverage edits to make next + 1 thing the writer is doing exceptionally well. Honest, generous, not destructive. Plain English. DRAFT: {{draft}}
Run in

Fill in the required fields above to copy or run this prompt.

Tags

critiqueeditingreviewcraft

Community Feedback

0 comments
Be the first to leave feedback on this prompt.

Related Prompts

More in Writing
Claude
#writing

Rewrite for a specific audience

Rewrites a piece tailored to a specific audience's knowledge level, vocabulary, and concerns.

0.0(0)
Copy
Claude
#writing

Suggest titles for an essay

Generates 12 title options for an essay across different positioning angles.

0.0(0)
Copy
Claude
#writing

Write a one-sentence summary

Distils a long piece into a single, faithful sentence under 25 words.

0.0(0)
Copy
ChatGPT
#writing

Convert raw notes to summary

Converts messy raw notes into a clean summary with key points and actions.

0.0(0)
Copy